On to the Next

dav

Argentina never disappoints.  It was a short trip, but as ever, I got a lot done.  Not being able to attend the Federation of International Polo’s General Assembly this year, I was able to meet Horacio Areco (pictured above), the new President of FIP, and the executive of Alejandro Taylor and Felipe Del Sel.  We covered Zone D issues such as the upcoming SEA Games in the Philippines, the World Championships and up-coming play-offs. 

On Friday, I went to watch the final of the Tortugas Open between La Dolfina and Ellerstina.  It had been rain-delayed.  The match continued from where it had ended.  La Dolfina dominated early on, but Ellerstina never gave up.  Down by four or five goals for much of the match Ellerstina came back in the last two chukkas to pip La Dolfina  12 – 11.  It was a very exciting match.

In Argentina, there has been a controversy raging over the quality of umpires being used in the Open matches.  The AAP has shouldered out the most established, and best umpires, because they work in America’s World Polo League.  These umpires are recognised as the best in the world by the players, but they are not allowed to work their trade at the top level in their own country.  It is an incredible situation brought about by business and polotics.

There has been a public outcry by players, who have even taken to social media to vent their frustration.

Pololine, the very influential polo e-zine published an on-line article, titled, Let’s protect the important matches.  Pololine’s comment:

It shows a clear lack of judgement that umpires who do have sufficient skills to deal with a game of this magnitude were not called on for the opportunity. Umpires like Federico Martelli, Gaston Dorignac, Esteban Ferrari, Daniel Boudou, Martín Aguerre, to name a few. Both parties need to be able to compromise, so that the spectacle can be played out as it should.

There have been occasions when umpiring standards have been high, particularly in Triple Crown finals, but there have also been many matches where the umpires have impaired the development of the game. This is the general consensus, regardless of the analysis of their verdicts.

It was very interesting for me to watch the Tortugas Open final sitting with two of those umpires, who, between them have umpired more than Argentine Open finals than anyone two others.

Their thinking of the situation is that they are the collateral damage victims of a conflict between the AAP and the World Polo League.

The next day, the Argentine Open started, and there was yet more criticism of the umpires.  After an accident, there were players who had been on the field, openly questioning the ability of the umpires on social media, including Facebook.  After looking at replays, Guillermo Terrara, an 8-goaler that had been on-field for La Dofina Polo Ranch, called the umpires “a disaster.”

Once the umpires lose the respect of players, it is extremely difficult to get it back.  I think that will be AAP’s biggest challenge now.

I got home last night, but have a really bad cough.  I leave again on Friday for the SEA Games Polo in Calatagan, Philippines.  We have challenges of our own.  Some of the stewards and even the Technical Delegate, John Fischer, have yet to receive their plane tickets.  One International Technical Official (ITO) has not even got a visa issued yet, and we have had to ask for emergency intervention to try to speed one through.

Hopefully, these issues get sorted out, and we can concentrate on what we are there for – playing polo.

 

Please follow and like us:
Pin Share